This is a first for me — I have entirely deleted the initial entry for Cartlidge & Browne and revisited the winery after an unpleasant experience occurred during my first visit. For those coming to this blog entry months (or years?) after the incident occurred, the greatly abbreviated version is that an elderly man working in the tasting room did something offensively inappropriate which I documented. I now regret that write-up and wish instead that I had gone directly to management privately with what transpired. However, in response to the complaint, the winery reacted swiftly, with compassion, and immense understanding. Elijah Selby, the Hospitality Director and Winery Relations wrote me an astonishing letter of apology which displayed superlative behavior and personal insight. She also accepted my heartfelt regret and apology about the situation and a great friendship was born out of an otherwise ugly situation.
Cartlidge & Browne is a considerably larger operation than one would imagine. As a negociant production facility, they purchase the bulk of their grapes of premiere as well as little-known vineyards from all over the state and have been making wine for over twenty-five years. Their own production is in the 140,000 case load, but they are a huge, thriving facility doing custom crush work for a number of additional wineries in the area.
Their winemaking facilities are located in a large warehouse in American Canyon, which is not exactly the jewel-bedecked, glamorous winery country that most folks think of when considering visiting Napa. It is a mostly industrial area that people drive through on their way to Napa from San Francisco and is known for housing that necessary part of the wine industry like barrel makers, label printers, and large shipping firms. But lying almost exactly in the center of the otherwise sleepy hamlet, off the main drag of Highway 29, are the signs for Greenfield Winery‘s tasting room. (Greenfield is a secondary label of Cartlidge & Browne’s and I am guessing, but have not had it confirmed, that it is simply easier to have signs directing passers-by to "Greenfield" than to a longer-named "Cartlidge & Browne."
Lamar is the manager of the tasting room which, because it is physically part of the warehouse, is decidedly chilly. On my first visit (where no wines were actually tasted), a lovely girl named Abigail began our conversation with a warning that if I had a sweatshirt to wear, it might be advisable to put on, for while it was almost ninety degrees outside, the building is kept at a chilly 55 degrees for the wine. However, Elijah (whom I regret I did not photograph) is already talking about expanding to the suite next door for a potential new tasting room which might ultimately be more comfortable for visitors.
There are three labels produced by Cartlidge & Browne’s winemaker, Paul Moser (who has been with the firm an astonishing quarter of a century); the Cartlidge & Browne label, Greenfield, and Stratford, which is primarily made for exporting to the United Kingdom but is available for purchase in the tasting room. A new product in the line-up came about through a painting which owner, Tony Cartlidge, saw and purchased in New York. The painting was purchased and THEN a wine was developed to match the artwork! Rabid Red was made as the winery’s first blend wine and the entire packaging model with the insane-looking dog’s head has been a tremendous success with Gen-Xers. However, the product inside the crazy bottle is astonishingly great for its price point of $15.00. Having been given an early taste of the 2004 vintage, it is easy to see why the winery has made the decision to double and potentially triple its production. Overall, Cartlidge & Browne is all about making tremendously affordable wines at a consistently high quality. Bottle prices start as little as $2.99 and top out at a whopping $20.00. I did not have the price list in front of me when I did my tasting and seriously thought the price range was four and five times higher than they actually are (and perhaps they should be!) I have blogged other wineries who produce products in this price range that did not have anywhere near the consistency and quality I found in Cartlidge & Browne and I am pleased to have found such a wide variety of wines that I can now personally start buying.
2004 Cartlidge & Browne Sauvignon Blanc – Bright notes of tropical fruit and spicy pineapple with a hint of kiwi. A swirl produces darker green apple tones. Very crisp with a tangy mid-palate. $9.92
2004 Cartlidge & Browne Chardonnay – Astonishing aroma of lemon meringue with deeper layers of mango. Silky entry is easy and well-balanced with a tangy, heightened lemony finish. $9.92
2004 Cartlidge & Browne Pinot Noir – Intense fresh raspberry and cherry bouquet with a depth of dark cinnamon. Spicy entry is smooth and shows well-sculpted depth. $9.92
NV Greenfield Sunset Cuvee – 70% Chardonnay and 30% Muscat Canelli. Sweet, enticing nose of exotic floral and citrus aromas. A touch of sweetness on the tongue produces a clean citrusy taste that is simply, easy, and fun. $4.17
2001 Cartlidge & Browne Merlot – Dusty floral bouquet. Predominately black plum flavors in a smooth mouthfeel with a slightly peppery finish. $5.00
2003 Rabid Red – 47% Cabernet Sauvignon (from Monterey), 31% Syrah (from the Sierras), 19% Zinfandel (Napa), and 3% Viognier (Lodi). Spicy, enticing nose with black plum and blackberry tones. Very easy and smooth mouth entry that blossoms to show rich, easy-to-drink daily wine. $15.00
2004 Rabid Red – To be released in September… 35% Cabernet Sauvignon, 28% Petite Sirah, 18% Syrah, 17% Tempranillo, 15 Grenache, and 1% Zinfandel. Deep, dark inky color with opulent blueberry bouquet. Blackberry liqueur shows on the initial, smooth taste that displays continuing and enticing all the way to a developed, fabulous finish. My new favorite wine for the price. $15.00
2003 Manzanita Canyon Cabernet Sauvignon – Perfumey with dark cherry qualities. Light bodied Cab that is easy to drink. $7.00
2001 Stratford, Knights Valley – Dark plum tones show immediately but subside to develop layers of green bell pepper (barely) and woodsy qualities finishing in eucalyptus tones. Sharp, tight entry blossoms into dark cherry. Needs time. $9.00
2002 Cartlidge & Browne Syrah – Initial herbal qualities on the front back down to display meaty black, jammy fruit. Heightened acid on the entry is nice and chewy showing well-balanced, spicy, well-integrated fruit. $9.92
Cartlidge & Browne Winery / Greenfield Winery ~ 205 Jim Oswald Way, Ste. B ~ American Canyon ~ CA 94503 ~ 707-552-5199